Carrier Lift Store:



SALE: Nigel Foster Sea Kayaking DVDs
6 DVD Set from Renowned Paddler Nigel Foster
Become a Better Paddler Today!
On Sale Now! Save $30 + Free Shipping
 
Advice, Suggestions and General Help New Topic Printer Friendly Version

  What a piece of junk!
  Posted by: Captainc on Aug-05-08 7:35 AM (EST)
   Category: unassigned 

So I just went out and got this Garmin Foretrex 205 to help me with my multi-sport training program. I strap this baby on my wrist, climb onto the treadmill, and start jogging. The machine says I'm doing 6 MPH, but the Foretrex isn't registering ANYTHING. So I think, yeah, this is a pretty pricey device, obviously made for experienced, intense athletes, it probably hasn't been designed to record such slow times. So I kick the machine up to 8mph--still no reading. 10 mph--still no reading. 12 mph--nope. I notch it up to 15 mph, which is as high as my treadmill goes, and still nothing.

So I jump on my bike, attached to my top of the line fluid trainer. I start spinning, and the cyclo computer is reading 18 mph, then 20, then 28--and this stupid Garmin Foretrex is still reading ZERO MPH!!!

What a piece of junk! Obviously NOT made for the serious multi-sport athlete. I highly recommend you not waste your change on this toy.

Table of Contents




Messages in this Topic

 
  You sure you have good batteries?
  Posted by: grayhawk on Aug-05-08 7:49 AM (EST)
 
 
  it may not be the batteries
  Posted by: bohemia on Aug-07-08 10:30 AM (EST)
somtimes there's a little piece of plastic that you have to pull out before the battery will make contact
 
 
  And after a few beers
  Posted by: rWVen on Aug-05-08 7:53 AM (EST)
it won't tell you how high you are...
 
 
  Not to state the obvious, but on p.net
  Posted by: string on Aug-05-08 8:17 AM (EST)
you never know.My GPS doesn't show anything if I stay in one spot either.
 
 
  Are you on the treadmill indoors?
  Posted by: Andy_Szymczak on Aug-05-08 8:17 AM (EST)
If so, that's why it's not working.

Andy
 
 
  You guys have been had!
  Posted by: BNystrom on Aug-05-08 8:23 AM (EST)
This is obviously a tongue-in-cheek post. Either that or Captainc is dumber than dirt.
 
 
  ...
  Posted by: amr on Aug-05-08 8:23 AM (EST)
It seems to me if you are staying in one spot on a treadmill, the GPS sensor will detect that you are actually going nowhere.
 
 
  Sounds like..
  Posted by: focus on Aug-05-08 8:35 AM (EST)
..it's reading perfectly.

Tom
 
 
  You obviously don't understand
  Posted by: captainc on Aug-05-08 8:49 AM (EST)
how GPS is supposed to work. It stands for Global POSITIONING System. It sends a signal to a satellite, which aims an x-ray camera back at you, and measures the movement (i.e. "position") of your arms and legs. When you pay over $200 bucks for something, it should work, even indoors, if the X-ray cameras it is linked to are any good. Garmin has obviously not subscribed to the best satellite X-rays cameras, which should easily read through my roof. It's not like its lead-lined or anything. They are ripping people off.
 
 
  Ha, funny!
  Posted by: JayH on Aug-05-08 9:06 AM (EST)
"It sends a signal to a satellite, which aims an x-ray camera back at you, and measures the movement (i.e. "position") of your arms and legs. "

Yeah, sends a signal to a satellite.. HAHAHAHA

Jay
 
 
  hmm
  Posted by: swedge on Aug-05-08 9:27 AM (EST)
My GPS works fine indoors, you got a defective one, go take it back to Toys R Us..
 
 
  you're missing an accessory
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-05-08 9:50 AM (EST)
...for the x ray cameras to find and identify you, you need to purchase the antenna, which will cancel out the effects of your foil beanie.
 
 
  Worth a try
  Posted by: captainc on Aug-05-08 10:20 AM (EST)
Where can I get that? It doesn't seem to be sold at my local Wal-Mart.
 
 
  if you can't find the foil beanie
  Posted by: BETMKaplan on Aug-05-08 12:27 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Aug-05-08 12:31 PM EST --

at your local Wal-Mart, try covering your pith helmet with Reynolds Wrap Release and form a swan antenna on top. You know, like they do when you take home food from a fancy restaurant.
Shine on, Kaps

 
 
  LMFAO
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-05-08 3:34 PM (EST)
I don't think Wal Mart has ever even considered selling foil beanies, as Wal-Mart stores are built with giant foil beanie roofing systems to protect the general populace.
 
 
  spoof woof
  Posted by: kozmikarl on Aug-05-08 9:08 AM (EST)
I guess there wouldn't be much traffic on a dedicated silly message board. It does seem unkind, not to mention oddly pointlessly time-consuming, to post absurdities just to take advantage of the kindness of strangers and the gullibility of people less sophisticated in pranksterism.

Puns, it turns out, are the second lowest form of humor.
 
 
  joke
  Posted by: lordsponge on Aug-05-08 9:25 AM (EST)
It's a joke guys. geeez
 
 
  Try the Foretex 101
  Posted by: puddlefish on Aug-05-08 9:42 AM (EST)
I picked one up for fifty bucks. Not flashy, but works fine.
 
 
  I used to have a foretrex
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-05-08 9:50 AM (EST)
...but my parents had it removed
 
 
  Changes in latitudes
  Posted by: waterspyder on Aug-05-08 10:29 AM (EST)
In order to make the GPS work properly you need to adjust it to the proper latitude. The Jimmy Buffet principle explains this effect and he's discovered the problem behind your GPS showing you running in place. Clearly he's referring to the condition you refer to in your OP since he discusses running in his theory. To solve the problem you merely need to change your latitude which will result in a corresponding change in your attitude towards the GPS. Since the theory is complex it is often useful to consume a few mararita's while studing it's effect.


"It's these changes in latitudes, changes in attitudes
Nothing remains quite the same
With all of our running and all of our cunning
If we couldn't laugh we would all go insane"
 
 
  *L*
  Posted by: swedge on Aug-05-08 11:58 AM (EST)
Doh...
 
 
  is this a quiz ?
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-05-08 12:11 PM (EST)
I am assuming from the brand (Garmin) you are talking about a GPS based unit. If you are not moving, you shouldn't expect it to calculate velocity.
 
 
  Holy cr@p
  Posted by: Pyker on Aug-05-08 12:21 PM (EST)
I know it's a message board and something get's lost in the translation from the written word. But has our nation become so focused that we can't tell a joke when we seen one!

Dude where's Coffee when you need him.
Randy
 
 
  Are you
  Posted by: phij on Aug-05-08 2:47 PM (EST)
pointing it at the satellites the proper way? I have a Garmin E-trex Legend and I've found that if I don't point it right at the satellites it won't work...and make sure you do it during day light hours while they're still visible...
 
 
  Perhaps it's calibrated in
  Posted by: georgia_kayaker on Aug-05-08 3:31 PM (EST)
inches per minute. Put it on your back during sex and see if it records.

G_K
 
 
  Heard a rumor...................
  Posted by: thebob.com on Aug-05-08 3:42 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Aug-05-08 3:50 PM EST --

Heard a rumor that aliens are stealing aluminum & copper parts from some of the satellites. May be affecting some of the satellite's functions?

The gray ones are some theiving little bast..ds.

I bought a new Garmin Pretext.
I assume it is working correctly.
It gives the appearance of quality.
Haven't tried the cloaking feature yet.

:^)

BOB

 
 
  On my back!?
  Posted by: Delphinus on Aug-05-08 4:54 PM (EST)
But I'm usually on the bottom ...
 
 
  Inches per minute...
  Posted by: Dsorgnzd on Aug-06-08 3:26 PM (EST)
Do you really think "2....2....2....2....2....2" is going to help him in his training?
 
 
  problem
  Posted by: postalgbv on Aug-05-08 3:49 PM (EST)
you have to hold the face of the device perfectly perpendicular to Garmin's stationary satellite. You should have received a 10" brass sextant with your purchase and if not, contact Garmin immediately.
 
 
  Mine works fine...
  Posted by: coffeeII on Aug-05-08 4:05 PM (EST)
"Obviously NOT made for the serious multi-sport athlete"

That is funny a "serious multi-sport athlete" that sits indoors on a stationary bike & a treadmill... HAHAHAHAHAHA!

If you were "serious" and an actual "multi-sport athlete", you would be outside & more than just running and biking.

Go outdoors & it should work just fine.

Paddle easy,

Coffee
 
 
  Maybe it's
  Posted by: georgia_kayaker on Aug-05-08 6:05 PM (EST)
multi-sport resistant.

G_K
 
 
  Think harder!
  Posted by: phreon on Aug-05-08 6:16 PM (EST)
Did you attach the required satellite dish? Good lord, how do you expect the electro-bits will make it up into space without the required 8 foot antenna and tracking system?

Sheesh!

Phreon
 
 
  Sell
  Posted by: dreamweve on Aug-05-08 6:50 PM (EST)
Since I don't go anywhere,just to help you out,I would be willing to give you half price for it. At least you would get some of your money back
 
 
  Return it for the Garmin Forehead 666
  Posted by: JayH on Aug-05-08 7:14 PM (EST)
Stick it on your forehead and it'll implant a sense of speed in your mind. Want to go faster, just think harder and the Garmin Forehead will implement a sense of speed.

Jay
 
 
  Attach it to
  Posted by: redmond on Aug-06-08 7:22 AM (EST)
your foot. Then it'll read something!
 
 
  Strap it to your chest...
  Posted by: cd1 on Aug-06-08 7:34 AM (EST)
...if it reads zero, you're legally dead.
 
 
  Try using it
  Posted by: larryn on Aug-06-08 2:54 PM (EST)
on a staionary rowing machine and see how it works. It is possible the slaemans sold you the model designed just for paddling.
 
 
  it's obvious
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-06-08 5:00 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Aug-06-08 5:01 PM EST --

the treadmill is running in the opposite direction of the earth's rotation, cancelling out your progress.

Try moving the treadmill outside, and place it perpendicular to the earth's rotation. Use the compass on your gps to make sure.

 
 
  Electronic do-dads, often hopeless
  Posted by: TrentRiver on Aug-06-08 5:45 PM (EST)
Sounds like the hand-held digital anemometer my loving wife got me for my birthday. The money would have been better spent on a good (or even mediocre) bottle of Pinot Noir.
 
 
  Next we can try
  Posted by: Zapblam on Aug-07-08 12:04 AM (EST)
duct taping the fishfinder transducer to the rubber ducky to read the water temps in the hottub and find that step. Use the extra bits of tape to fashion the beanie for your GPS lazer signal booster.
 
 
  This is why,
  Posted by: Grump on Aug-07-08 5:47 AM (EST)
I bolted my treadmill to the front of my kayak. Now when I paddle I know just how fast I am going, and it is very accurate!-)
 
 
  My GPS takes 2 - AA batteries
  Posted by: georgia_kayaker on Aug-07-08 10:22 AM (EST)
What size and how many does the treadmill take?

Paddlin' on
G_K
 
 
  What a moron...
  Posted by: coffeeII on Aug-07-08 6:54 AM (EST)
And you all wonder why these people irritate me eith their lack on common sense.

captain must be the leader?

Paddle easy,

Coffee
 
 
  Great thread responses.
  Posted by: puddlefish on Aug-07-08 3:16 PM (EST)
I'm laughing til I'm crying.

Most amused that coffee doesn't seem to get it.
 
 
  I liked the reynolds wrap swan antenna..
  Posted by: old_user on Aug-07-08 3:26 PM (EST)
..but I mean, that guy just has no common sense.
 
 
  I get it... Just fine.
  Posted by: coffeeII on Aug-07-08 4:33 PM (EST)
Paddle easy,

Coffee
 
 
  GPS subscription
  Posted by: rosborn45 on Aug-10-08 2:16 PM (EST)
Hi, I'm from the government and I'm here to help. It's a good thing you didn't try to use that GPS unit outside, or I might be coming after you. GPS service is provided to qualified US citizens on a subscription basis. Anyone using an unregistered GPS device is subject to a fine and/or imprisonment, and we know who and where you are. Since this appears to be an innocent mistake, I will simply withdraw funds from your bank account to cover a background investigation and the GPS subscription. Thank you for bringing this matter to our attention.
 

Google
 
Web Paddling.net


©2010 Paddling.net Inc. Free Newsletter | Site Map | Advertising Info | Contact Us