Difference between sea kayaking & wwk.it
Posted by: chemenway on Mar-21-14 1:31 PM (EST) Category: Kayaks
Hi: Could anyone tell me the difference between sea kayaking and white water kayaking? Specifically, I am wondering if learning or trying white water kayaking would help me to improve my sea kayak paddle strokes or would it just mess me up. My personal kayak is a 16.5 Tsunami. The one time I was in a ww kayak was in a pool, and all I did was spin around in circles. :-( I have been wanting to head out to Zoar Outdoor in Western, MA to give their ww kayak school a try. I have to admit, ww kayaking looks like it would be quite a bit of fun, although very different than paddling my giant kayak in the ocean or on lakes.
Great Products from the Buyers' Guide:
- Difference between sea kayaking & wwk.it - chemenway - Mar-21-14 1:31 PM
Go for it .....|
Posted by: seadart on Mar-21-14 1:39 PM (EST)
Once you try moving water you will be hooked.
| || |
It helps a lot|
Posted by: Celia on Mar-21-14 1:54 PM (EST)
You learn to paddle better for starters. What the spinning in circles was telling you was that your forward stroke is not efficient. It is just that you aren't being so penalized for it in a longer boat. And you are more likely to be in a group of people who consider a roll to be not-optional. In fact all it usually takes is a couple of times down your first class 2 to figure that out yourself. It is sooo much easier to roll than to have to be rescued off a damned rock that you can't figure out how to get off without some help.
And if you ever paddle anywhere there is significant tidal influence, like around the openings of river that go out to the sea, what you learn in class II whitewater is right on the mark for what you need to do in a sea kayak in the tidal zones. This is a terribly under-prepared area for a lot of long boaters. They often find out there is a gap in their skills when they end up on vacation somewhere with serious tidal influence and are unable to get back to where they started. It is not a comfortable feeling.
It is also kind of fun to go out in a WW boat because everything is so scaled down from lugging around the boat and gear for open water.
| || |
Posted by: Peter-CA on Mar-21-14 7:04 PM (EST)
Celia, thanks for the great response.
| || |
I'll just add|
Posted by: rjd9999 on Mar-22-14 11:28 AM (EST)
that WW paddling is more technical, in that you must frequently make adjustments, execute your strokes with more precision (and timing), and move your body as one with the boat. All that is excellent training for those moments in sea kayaking where you suddenly find yourself in conditions that require precise boat handling.
Anything you do wrong in a short WW kayak is amplified because the boat has (usually) a rounded bottom and no keel. If you have an unbalanced stroke, you will, as you point out, spin in circles. The length and the keel of sea kayaks help the boat resist forces that turn the boat (but it doesn't eliminate them - following seas or those times when you are on the top of a wave/swell when the hull has reduced contact with the water will reveal imbalances fairly dramatically).
In short, WW kayaking should enhance, not detract from your skills.
| || |
Preferences vary, obviously, but|
Posted by: bignate on Mar-21-14 2:57 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Mar-21-14 2:58 PM EST --
If it looks interesting, you should definitely give it a go. I also started out doing exclusively sea kayaking and now rarely do anything but river paddling, not because I dislike sea kayaking, but due to simple convenience. If you like ocean kayaking, I think there's a good chance you'll enjoy river paddling. Fundamentally, they're really not that different (and there's no rule against taking your sea kayak out on the river).
And yes, river paddling will definitely help your sea kayaking and shouldn't interfere with your existing stroke repertoire. Celia is spot-on with respect to the benefits of river paddling in developing your skills in tidal environments, not only with respect to boat control and strokes, but also your ability to read moving water.
The one small quibble I have is that I don't necessarily agree that spinning out a WW boat indicates a lack of efficiency in your forward stroke in the abstract, but rather simply that you haven't yet learned to adapt to the most efficient stroke for a much smaller, turn-ier boat. Assuming you have a good forward stroke now, you will almost certainly learn to adapt it quickly.
| || |
l may have overshot that..|
Posted by: celia on Mar-21-14 4:24 PM (EST)
l was responding to the sense that the oper didn't seem to grab what was wrong with the stroke in the ww boat quickly. But you are right - that is not necessarily the same as their stroke being inefficient in a longer boat
| || |
I agree about form|
Posted by: trvlrerik on Mar-21-14 7:32 PM (EST)
I switch from WW boats to touring boats regularly, the only thing that can screw me up is edging in steering, WW boats lean into the turn to edge, opposite of touring edging.
WW padding often has a higher cadence interrupted by catches and altered strokes that really teach good form quickly. Bad form is often punished just as quickly.
| || |
The differences feel bigger at first|
Posted by: pikabike on Mar-22-14 12:56 AM (EST)
With practice, paddling either one in a straight line will feel normal. But a WW boat definitely is harder to keep tracking when you first try it.
I'm not even going to try to answer your first question. As for the second question, taking a WW class will not "screw up" your stroke. If anything, it should help you, because the boats are inherently more sensitive (or less forgiving) to asymmetry in your stroke or your sitting position.
The only thing that might be screwy-uppy is that you're adding more people telling you how to do things, and even within one discipline you'll already get differing and sometimes opposing advice!
| || |
I just tried a sea kayak for the first |
Posted by: tdaniel on Mar-22-14 7:46 AM (EST)
time back in November. I found the switch from ww to be a humbling experience. I started off in one of cast offs sea kayak's and right away ended up swimming at the access point while trying to get a feel for the edges. In the sea kayak I felt like I had to keep my weight centered in the middle of the boat for any sense of stability, and from my perspective the boat only wanted to go straight- not turn, but I was amazed at the forward progress I could make even in windy conditions and how light the boats were, given their length. I liked it and will give it go again. It may be some time before I'm ready for open water.
I think the most important aspect of either paddling experience is risk assessment- identifying and understanding the hazards that each new environment imposes and planning accordingly.
Nothing wrong with commercial outfits for ww instruction, although I like the club clinic route. While the instruction may not be as good, you would be more likely to meet other potential paddling partners, and get additional support for follow up sessions at a pool or on a beginners trip. I'd check for local ww clubs or groups in your area.
| || |
BTW, Zoar is a great place to start|
Posted by: Celia on Mar-22-14 9:04 AM (EST)
I have gotten over to the Deerfirld with a group a couple or three times. There were some alterations after Irene, but reports are that it is still a great training run taught by good people. I can say that all of the folks I saw in their classes (we were in a club clinic) seemed to be having a great time.
There are some iconic smaller smaller family run hotels around there if you don't want to camp. Don't expect the Hilton, but we like funky.
| || |
Different enough not to mess you up IMO|
Posted by: OptiMystic on Mar-22-14 11:10 AM (EST)
May help some, but the way the boats are steered and react to paddling is different enough that you won't be confused between them. After a long hard paddle in each type of boat, while there is a lot of overlap it is a different set of muscles that will be tired.
I have yet another take on the spinning in circles. In a touring boat, you point the boat and paddle to move it in that direction. In a whitewater boat, you stick the paddle in the water ahead of you and pull on it as if it were fixed, placing your feet where they need to be next. Sounds odd, but when I approach it that way I find a ww boat much easier to control.
| || |
Disagree a bit|
Posted by: Celia on Mar-22-14 12:41 PM (EST)
A good paddle stroke does not change regardless of boat. In all boats, if your paddle is still actively in the water behind your hip, it'll draw the stern of the boat that way and cause the bow to head in the opposite of the desired direction. In all boats, if you are entering the water with more of a sweep angle stroke than a straight one, it'll affect the direction of the bow and rob energy from the power phase of the stroke.
The difference is in how responsive the boat is to those habits. In a long boat, especially a less rockered one, its tendency to go straight is such that you can make a bunch of smaller mistakes and not notice it except for some loss of power and forward speed.
In a whitewater boat, it responds much faster to all of these errors. If it is a playboat rather than the higher volume creekers, it will respond faster to the body going off center than a lot of long boats. A lot of folks getting into WW now are doing it creekers or more protective river runners, rather than the smaller playboats that were favored when the new paddlers were a younger population than now.
By planting the paddle aggressively forward in the WW boat, you are probably shortening the distance that the paddle will be drawn back behind your hip. I suspect the way you are thinking about it also creates a straighter draw back, rather than the kinda-sweep kinda-straight stroke that is a common habit in longer boats because of all the automatic corrections for wind and waves.
But a forward stroke is a forward stroke. It is just that the combination of smaller WW boas and pushier water tells you about your mistakes a lot faster than in a leisurely paddle in a long boat.
I agree that the muscles that hurt can be different after each type of paddle, but when I was on my game I often found the difference in my core muscles. I could get lazy on a long paddle in the sea kayak and do some minor barcalounging. Even in my dicier smaller boat we have enough miles that I can relax and let the boat handle a lot of issues. But in a WW boat, because the water is constantly pushing me around, I can't laze down the river.
| || |
The ww boats I paddled spun on a dime|
Posted by: OptiMystic on Mar-23-14 4:50 PM (EST)
With a nickel in change ;->
Pointing the boat had little bearing (pun intended) on where I was headed. I moved my body where it needed to be and the boat came with it. In touring or even rec boats, where the boat is pointed has significantly more impact on where I am headed and like you, I have found I can get away with being a little lazier sometimes. I can coast a little here and there, skipping a stroke or two and still maintain my heading or very nearly so.
The "plant the paddle and move your feet" advice often worked for people who were having trouble steering a ww boat, but I am very aware that it is just a way of thinking about it and that you could watch me do it and point out that most of my strokes are still fairly standard forward strokes. Thinking this way just helps keep the core engaged.
| || |
Shallow water more dangerous|
Posted by: jaybabina on Mar-22-14 12:58 PM (EST)
Generally shallow water (with a current) is more dangerous that deep water. Going far off shore is more dangerous than being close to shore.
As always, it boils down to conditions.
| || |
"Ferrying isn't a WW specific skill"|
Posted by: pikabike on Mar-24-14 6:28 PM (EST)
Yup, and neither is edging on the inside of the turn. Best to think more of water forces and conditions than what labels of boats.
But I think there is another factor at work, namely that of familiarity with the type of moving water the paddler started in first. The environment.
My first combat roll was in ocean surf, then tidal river--both of them in a sea kayak--and only then in a freshwater river. Since I could roll both my sea kayak and my WW kayak equally well in flat water, and since the water was much "bigger" in the sea locations than in the freshwater river, I think the hold-up for me was more psychological than anything else. After that, the mental hurdle got downsized. Not eliminated, just downsized. I may never get rid of the lurking image of one-way nontidal river current sweeping me awaaaaaay past any bailouts. There is something about knowing that waves go back and forth, and tidal flows reverse, that makes it easier for me to deal with those.
Eddies are good ;-)
| || |
I thought that was an odd comment also|
Posted by: OptiMystic on Mar-24-14 8:55 PM (EST)
I don't know anyone who does any serious touring who can't ferry. It's a basic skill to safely navigate a lot of inlets, especially if there are jetties and other structures.
| || |
that paragraph reminded me|
Posted by: trvlrerik on Mar-24-14 10:09 PM (EST)
Of one of my first ocean lessons, kept me out of open water for a long time. His favorite catch phrase was "laugh at the ocean and it will kill you".
| || |
and that reminds me of an instructor|
Posted by: OptiMystic on Mar-25-14 6:41 AM (EST)
I took a course from, but it was avalanche training for back country. When we did peeps training he told us he wanted to dispel the common notion that Peeps made it safe to ski in avalanche prone areas. "You wear a transmitter so your friends won't get too cold looking for your body." I don't think I would want to be an instructor in adventure sports; people die from not learning to do things properly.
| || |
One of those long boat confusions|
Posted by: Celia on Mar-25-14 8:15 AM (EST)
People call anything 14 ft and up a sea kayak, and the person paddling it a sea kayaker, whether or not they'd know what to do with breaking waves at their stern coming into a landing. And I have been out with WW folks who were astounded that everyone out of a pod of several people in a sea kayak could roll at all, let alone in any moving water. (There is a nice practice area just below a class 2 run locally that is great for getting your boat under you each spring.)
Personally I don't call everyone in a long boat a sea kayaker, because there are many I would not want to actually be on the sea with. There is a category of flat water paddler that truly needs flat water, and even ocean bays on a cranky day aren't flat.
But there is no way I have ever found to identify this. Lake paddler? Try Champlain on a day when the wind has been blowing hard out of the north or south over a long fetch... it is hardly flat.
| || |
Posted by: emanoh on Mar-25-14 12:22 PM (EST)
Maybe we need to put some basic rating recomendations together for paddlers in general. Moving water paddlers rate themselves based on what rapids they feel meets their ability. ACA has some basic 1-5 levels for instruction purposes. Since conditions change so much for open water, maybe the industry needs to have a basic clasification. Maybe there is one and I've missed it?
For example Class I boater rates for slow rivers and windless/waveless inland lakes and bays. A Class V boater is comfortable most coastal or open water environments with conditions exceeding X. Is comfortable performing various self and assisted rescues in same conditions?
Maybe the ACA levls are the "recognized" skill levels for paddlers, but I've only seen them in reference to the type of instruction, potential instructors will be able to instruct.
| || |
Been suggested but...|
Posted by: Celia on Mar-25-14 3:26 PM (EST)
Really, the only way to tell is to know who you paddle with.
| || |
Kayak doesn't make kayaker|
Posted by: emanoh on Mar-26-14 8:47 AM (EST)
Celia, I completely agree that just because you own a kayak doesn't make you a kayaker. Anytime I read about a rec boater who meets an untimely demise, we all get lumped together. Most of the time this person had zero knowledge, lack of understanding of the potential danger and a poorly outfitted boat for the situation. Zero knowledge of self rescue skills. No PFD. No immersion gear, etc. but we all get lumped together in the media.
| || |
I'm a sea kayaker|
Posted by: emanoh on Mar-26-14 8:50 AM (EST)
We have a club in our town that consists entirely of recreational boats and I bet 80% would consider themsleves sea kayakers. I attended one of their monthly meetings with a buddy who was asked to do a presenation on kayak sailing (I was there for moral support). As part of the discussion we talked about touring and all the things you needed to be on the water for a week or more. A portion of the presentation included our circumnavigation of Isle Royal in chilly Lake Superior (120 miles).
Afterwards one of the attendees came up to me all excited and said “I’m so glad you are here, I want to do what you guys do!” He started rattling off all his gear, “I have this tent, this sleeping bag,” etc. etc. He followed up with, “how do I get in with you on your trips?”
I didn’t know this guy from Adam, but after briefly talking about safety and having the conditioning to be on the water for a week or more, I got the sense that the guy had more spirit than ability. I asked “so what are you paddling, something in the 15-16ft range?” His response was, “I have this great 10ft sit on top kayak, its’ stable, I’ve never fallen out, I wear a wet suit, I have dry bags for my gear,” etc.
At that point in the conversation, I winced not wanting to go into all the reasons, he’d have a hard time joining on a true sea kayak touring trip. I also didn’t want to ding his enthusiasm for paddling but I wished him well, asked him if he’s paddled to a couple of neat places in the region and I mentioned he might want to give a sea kayak a try and gave him my email address. I haven’t heard from him, but nonethless, I guarantee that guy is a “sea kayaker.” If he reaches out I’ll gladly show him the ropes.
| || |
"Didn't want to ding his enthusiasm"|
Posted by: pikabike on Mar-26-14 4:43 PM (EST)
You're wise not to tread too heavily on the dire predictions and other scare tactics, even while trying to break the news to him. It's hard to find a balance. I've been on both sides of this equation.
What scares me is a common tendency for people to assume that because X started when/where/how the same way they did--or worse yet because they simply were acquainted with X--therefore they can do all the stuff that X now does. They conveniently overlook that X might have spend thousands of hours working on "boring" or "technique" building blocks that help get him or her from a wish to a reality. And that X always looked for more knowledge, never considering the status quo to be enough. Potential is not the same as making actual.
Another thing that scares me is the attempt to minimize real hazards that they have been warned about. A good example is the woman who approached me last fall after I returned from paddling in an area that novices are told in no uncertain terms to never go (strong currents, among other things). She asked hopefully, "You don't need to know much about the tides here, do you?" I was astounded by this question and tried to hide my dismay when I told her that, on the contrary it was very important to know about "the tides", especially the flow directions and speeds. I told her there was another area nearby where it was not critical, although helpful, but she wasn't interested in that. Instead, she asked, "What about such-and-such place?" where such knowledge was every bit as important. I finally had to say, "If you don't know the basics about tides and their flows, that is not the place to start."
But what probably happened afterwards was that she went fishing for a different answer more to her liking, from someone else. Hopefully, she went on a guided tour. It's hard to help someone who is trolling for approval rather than really trying to learn.
| || |
Ferrying is ferrying, sea or ww, unless |
Posted by: ezwater on Mar-31-14 11:59 PM (EST)
you happen to have a kayak that is really brilliant at ferrying. Flattish bottom, some rocker, distinct chines. All of my boats that have those characteristics (two OC-1s, a slalom c-1, and a Noah Magma) are absolutely brilliant at ferrying, being able to "fly" across strong currents at amazingly acute angles.
Otherwise, my roundish kayaks, c-1s, and OC-1s ferry acceptably, as long as I don't let the angle between the boat and the current get too large.
Specialized wave surfing kayaks would probably be brilliant at ferrying strong river currents. Might not be useful for much else on rivers, though.
| || |
Head to Zoar or anywhere for WW 101-|
Posted by: bigspencer on Mar-31-14 9:04 PM (EST)
104 (etc). Imho spending time in WW(ie moving water) is THE way to start, but it all starts with learning how to relax the hips and learn how to use upper/lower-body separation to one's advantage...
| || |