Your #1 source for kayaking and canoeing information.               FREE Newsletter!
my Profile
 





 
Advice, Suggestions and General Help New Topic Printer Friendly Version

  super low cost drysuit
  Posted by: dc9mm on Jan-19-14 11:15 AM (EST)
   Category: Other Gear 

I saw a post on another kayaking forum (West Coast paddler) about a new drysuit company offering a super low cost brethable drysuit. Just thought I would post a link to it. I dont no anything about the suit or the people making it BUT if its even half way decent looks like a good choice for those on a budget.

http://www.mythicdrysuits.com/products/sobek

 Great Products from the Buyers' Guide:

Mid-Hull Carts

Overstock Outlet Foods

Emergency Cases

Paddling Jackets

Table of Contents




Messages in this Topic

 

  Yup
  Posted by: kayamedic on Jan-19-14 12:48 PM (EST)
Bob Holtzman and a bunch of paddlers( most of them guides) from Maine feel that everyone needs a functional inexpensive drysuit for whitewater and sea kayaking.
 
 
  If it is reasonably durable
  Posted by: pblanc on Jan-19-14 1:59 PM (EST)
it will be a very good deal.

The weak spot of dry suits is often the interior seam sealing. Hopefully, someone on this forum will buy one and leave a review.

There are some apparent limitations of this suit. First, the base of the neck gasket appears to be very wide. This could make replacing the neck gasket with the commonly available replacement gaskets problematical. Before buying I would make sure that replacement neck gaskets are available, not only from the manufacturer, but also from a second party in case the maker does not survive the market.

Second, as was noted, the suit lacks an outer over skirt. This is not a huge deal, but an outer over skirt is useful for those who paddle kayaks or C1s with spray skirt, as the over skirt helps seal the tunnel of the spray skirt from water entry.

Third, the wrist and neck seals lack any covers. Latex seals exposed to UV will break down more quickly. The lack of covers at the wrist seals might make them more liable to tearing or other damage. The lack of gussets at the ankles will result in the legs of the suit tending to "bag" around the ankles, probably not a big deal to most.
 
 
  Great approach
  Posted by: willi_h2o on Jan-19-14 1:59 PM (EST)
Most folks will not do 1,000 mile expeditions of
Antarctica or Northern Norway - so why pay the
prices for an over-engineered drysuit.

A drysuit for the masses definitely fills a
distinctive void in the paddling marketplace.
 
 
  There's noting "overengineered"...
  Posted by: Bnystrom on Jan-20-14 8:23 AM (EST)
...about a high-quality, durable dry suit with useful features.

The weakness with (relatively) inexpensive dry suits has always been the fabrics, which typically are not durable and have no warranty when they fail. A dry suit that fails after a couple of seasons is no bargain. Hopefully this one will be different, but I'm not holding my breath.

It seems a bit odd to me that they chose to cover the zipper rather than the seals.

I disagree with the previous post regarding the size of the neck seal. It appears that it's the same diameter as a typical seal, it just doesn't have the wide flange/narrow tunnel shape that most dry suit neck seals have.
 
 
  One might also watch Sierra
  Posted by: ezwater on Jan-19-14 5:34 PM (EST)
Trading Outpost and other discounters for drysuits made by established makers. If a "breathable" drysuit fails, what can you do with it?
 
 
  I guess I will have to advise Bob
  Posted by: kayamedic on Jan-19-14 5:54 PM (EST)
to charge more!
 
 
  Tempting
  Posted by: Fred_Randall on Jan-20-14 10:46 AM (EST)
Strongly considering picking one of these up, if only to be a guinea pig for you guys. Curiosity usually gets the best of me. Will report back...
 
 
  Interesting...
  Posted by: mcimes on Jan-20-14 11:59 AM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Jan-20-14 12:01 PM EST --

This is exactly what Ive been wanting! I would only use a dry suit for a couple months in the early spring and late fall and have never been able to justify $500+ for what would probably be 15-30 uses per year. $250 however, is much easier to swing. Even if it only lasts a couple or 3 years, I'd call that good enough.

Considering if it lasts 3 years (probably more with semi infrequent use) that comes out to around $80 per year...that's a pretty hard price to beat for most other dry-suits. I know Kokat's are the Cadillac, but at $1000 retail and $80/year comparison, you need to keep it 12.5 years to pay it off. I know it will last that long with warranty, but thats a huge initial investment. Thats more than any of my boats!

Anyways thanks for posting this. I'm seriously considering one for this spring if taxes come back in my favor

 
 
  Thanks
  Posted by: blitzemall on Jan-21-14 9:28 AM (EST)
Really appreciate this post. Been looking at alternatives to Kokatat.
Have also been looking at this one:

http://www.activewake.com/oneill-boost-drysuit.html?gclid=CJKI6868j7wCFVQV7AodDx0A9g

These were made for wakeboarders, but thought it might cross over for kayaking.

O'neill seems to be well respected for customer service and the suit gets good reviews.
Anyone have any experience with it?
 
 
  the problem is when it fails ...
  Posted by: seadart on Jan-21-14 5:38 PM (EST)
The problem with a dry suit that starts leaking through a seam or the fabric gets saturated, is that you discover the problem when you are out in cold water, in rough conditions this could be a very big if not fatal problem. I watched a couple of people have drysuit failures while surfing in cold water, it did cause a fair amount of distress.

For a while you could purchase military surplus drysuits ( I think canadian air force?) they worked well for a while but tended to give out all at once.
 
 
  can't see the plus side...
  Posted by: RubricOfRuin on Jan-21-14 10:06 AM (EST)
in the economics of a 300 dollar suit vs 900 dollar suit. Time-proven fabric, life-time warranty and overall durability definitely outweights the cheaper price. Likely as not there is a reason for the price - as with everything. Over a lifespan of Kokatat drysuit - that is 10+ years if not 15+, 1000 dollars is miniscule investment into your safety on the water.

If it were easy to come up with products of the same qulity at 1/3 the price, there'd be no Kokatat, no Valley, no Tiderace... all those products are over-engineered and pretty useless for ordinary folk who do not do expeditions :)
 
 
  I don't think it has to be that way
  Posted by: Guideboatguy on Jan-21-14 10:35 AM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Jan-21-14 10:54 AM EST --

For any piece of gear with a warranty, that warranty is part of the cost (it's just like paying insurance), so the better the warranty, the more you pay for the product (does anyone think that Kokatat has such amazing customer service simply because they are so kind-hearted? They make money doing what they do. No company can survive by giving away products and service).

For a cheap dry suit, I'd agree with Pete that one of the biggest concerns would be how well the seams are sealed. I'm sure it costs more to do a good job of sealing seems, but I can't believe it costs $800 or $900 JUST for that aspect of the quality. The question is whether it can be done on a $200 suit, or whether the asking price for a suit with well-sealed seams needs to be higher than that. If the seams are well sealed, even a poorer-quality fabric that doesn't last as long can be worth the money as long as the price is low enough, especially for someone who only uses the suit once in a while and is therefore willing to put up with a fabric that's less breathable, less durable, etc. Only by trying out the suit will anyone know if that's the case here, but I'm not buying the idea that a suit has to cost $1,000 or $1,100 to be good enough (even though I own and use a Kokatat dry suit).

For what it's worth I also own a $200 dry suit. However, it's a military-surplus model, bought from a guy who purchased a whole bunch of them, so the original price was probably higher. The seam tape started coming loose the second year I used the suit, but I have no idea if the suit was two years old or twenty.

 
 
  My personal experience
  Posted by: pblanc on Jan-21-14 10:49 AM (EST)
with less expensive dry garments is that although the seam tapes are initially waterproof, they start to separate after a year or two.

I applaud the effort to bring a dry suit to the market at an entry level price and hope the manufacturer does well. I would be rather reluctant to use a suit with an unprotected neck gasket in significant whitewater since a torn or blown neck gasket can actually present a real hazard in the event of a longer swim.

Years ago, I bought an entry level dry suit from Kokatat (which has been long-since discontinued). I still have it as a backup. It is coated nylon with an unprotected neck gasket and a plastic zipper, ankle gaskets (no socks) and no relief zipper, no reinforcement at the knees or seat, and no exterior overskirt. Even though this was a Kokatat suit, I have had to reseal the seams a couple of times.

I think I paid about $250 for that suit and it served the purpose for a few years. At the time I could have purchased a new Kokatat Gore-Tex dry suit for about $300 more. In my case I would have been much better off to have gone with the more expensive suit but if I had not stuck with the sport, the cheaper one would have sufficed.
 
 
  Target buyer
  Posted by: dc9mm on Jan-21-14 11:22 AM (EST)
I think the target buyer is the guy/gal who spent less than 700 on a kayak and paddle combined and sure doesnt want to spend way more than that for a drysuit. This will give this person on that kind of budget the abilty to be safer in cold water.

I posted this here to see if we get somone to buy one and let the others know if its any good. Looks like it could be a perfect backup suit to my kokatat. I wonder if they could change the suit a little and get the nylon material around the kneck and wrist gaskets. Thats what I see as its worst feature.
 
 
  Another take on gaskets
  Posted by: Guideboatguy on Jan-21-14 11:38 AM (EST)
I think for a person who's only doing quiet-water paddling, having exposed gaskets is probably not such a big concern. However, even in quiet water, being quite far from shore might be reason enough to want the gasket's covered. This is just a case of weighing the chances of a tear against the consequences, where even though the risk of a tear is tiny, the consequences when far from shore would be far worse than when on a quiet river. So once again, the cheaper suit might be acceptable for a paddler who's not taking great risks in the first place.
 
 
  Come to Maine Canoe Symposium
  Posted by: kayamedic on Jan-21-14 11:54 AM (EST)
Bob will be there.

The target market is those paddlers who should be wearing one but can't afford it.. ie the thousand who paddle in Maine in whitewater season, which is in March.

Using Old Town canoes and often standing.. immersion is always a possibility.
 
 
  The manufacturer replies
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-21-14 2:59 PM (EST)
I'm Bob Holtzman, the president/founder of Mythic Gear. Nice to see this discussion, which addresses a lot of the issues that I considered when launching the company and developing specs for our first drysuit models.

Mythic's suits do indeed represent a compromoise -- one that we feel is reasonable for many, but not all, paddlers. We're trying to meet the needs (and budgets) of most paddlers, not the top 5% who place unusual demands on their gear and can afford the very best. So we think our suits will be of most interest to recreational kayakers, sea kayakers, canoeists, rafters, SUP'ers, and perhaps a few whitewater kayakers who are really strapped.

We're using breathable fabric, but not GoreTex. All seams are taped inside, and they're nicely waterproof. We didn't compromise on gaskets or zippers, but we did skip the overcuffs. Overcuffs do offer protection against mechanical hazards, and that's probably of greatest importance to serious whitewater kayakers. Since our suits have no overskirt, that's clearly not their main target. (A WW kayaker might do OK with a tight-fitting spray skirt, however.)

As for the UV protection offered by overcuffs: the amount of time your suit spends outdoors is really pretty limited, and a few hours a month won't have much effect. Most UV protection consists of keeping it in a dark closet when it's not in use.

We offer a one-year warranty, which we feel is sufficient for any hidden defects to be revealed, but saves paddlers a lot of money compared to the lifetime warranty of some other suits.

I use this metaphor: most drysuits are the equivalent of top-end luxury cars really nice, but offering so many features and enhancements that they're unaffordable to most people. Mythic has the equivalent of a well-made economy car: maybe not *quite* as nice, but it gets the job done competently at an affordable price.

Will be glad to take your calls and answer your questions personally. Thanks for your interest.
 
 
  Bob forgot to mention that he
  Posted by: kayamedic on Jan-21-14 3:52 PM (EST)
IS a paddler.

Bob will you have suits for people to examine at the 2014 Maine Canoe Symposium?
 
 
  Responding to questions
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-22-14 12:45 PM (EST)
Mythic drysuits will be available for inspection and sale at the Maine Canoe Symposium. Typically, we'll be selling only online, but MCS represents an exception, since I will be running the "store" for the benefit of the other vendors.

Regarding sizes: we'll be keeping a careful eye on fit and size preferences. If the demand is there (and we think it will be), we'll introduce a size XXL in the near future. XXXL and XS are also possibilities.
 
 
  Thank You!
  Posted by: Kudzu on Jan-21-14 5:03 PM (EST)
Excellent idea! When someone mentioned that high-dollar drysuits are made to last 10-15 years I thought "Whoa, some of us sea kayakers don't expect to be physically ABLE that far down the road."

Best of luck.
 
 
  hey
  Posted by: RubricOfRuin on Jan-24-14 9:47 AM (EST)
My gore-tex jacket is about 11 years old, I'd expect my dryisuit age as gracefully as I do ><

PS. Even I continue to get those hard-to-pronounce chronical conditions, of thich I managed two in 5 years, I still expect to wear out my Kokatat suit before I die, otherwise I'd be pissed as HELL! :D
 
 
  Bigger Sizes
  Posted by: ShadyClip on Jan-21-14 7:57 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Jan-23-14 1:10 AM EST --

Any chance of larger sizes? Your size chart seems to stop a bit on the small side. I have about a 52" chest before I layer and a size 12-13 foot, it would seem that nothing you make would fit me.

Also, is your company coming to Paddlesport in New Jersey this year?

 
 
  Being 74" tall,
  Posted by: tetonjohn on Jan-22-14 10:42 AM (EST)
looks like I'm outta luck (for now anyway).
 
 
  answers
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-22-14 2:23 PM (EST)
Shadyclip-- no plans to be in new jersey this year. regarding sIze, see my answer from earlier today. sorry to disappoint. hopefully we will grow big enough fast enough to satisfy these requests.
 
 
  thanks and kudos
  Posted by: slushpaddler on Jan-22-14 8:38 PM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Jan-22-14 8:40 PM EST --

Kudos for posting. Thanks for the mission, there's a demand for a drysuit that doesn't cost as much as a good used kayak. The paddling community needs more facilitation, not less.

I remember when people were skeptical about four cylinder engines also!

 
 
  QWS 2014 in Michigan ?
  Posted by: willi_h2o on Jan-22-14 7:22 PM (EST)
Would love to see one at the
Quiet Water Symposium in Michigan this year

http://www.quietwatersymposium.org/
 
 
  guinea pig
  Posted by: windwalker on Jan-22-14 11:03 PM (EST)
So any incentive for the first P-netter guinea pig?

Maybe free shipping?

I'd be willing to give one a try and put it to the test and write an honest review.

I used to have a Stohlquist Drysuit and felt so restrictive in it that I sold it and opted for a dry top and dry pants. But I will admit without the added security and confidence of staying dry that a dry suit offers when I roll my canoe, I find I tend to paddle more conservatively in the winter without it. So $225 seems reasonable to get back in the mix of things.
 
 
  no discounts for guinea pigs
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-23-14 12:03 PM (EST)
Hey Windwalker -- you're tough! We have the USA's cheapest drysuit and you want to beat us up on shipping even before they're available? (I'm still smiling; no harm in asking.)
We've already begun selling suits, and I expect we'll get some user reviews here soon after we ship them to customers. (We anticipate that we'll begin shipping in under a month.) And as soon as we can, we'll get a few samples out to the magazines for reviews.
 
 
  HeeHee
  Posted by: Guideboatguy on Jan-23-14 12:06 PM (EST)
I almost posted something last night along those lines, but bit my tongue instead. "Yeah, that's an amazing price for what seems like it might be a good product. I'd love to own one, but only if you do ME a favor first."
 
 
  Lol
  Posted by: windwalker on Jan-23-14 12:18 PM (EST)
I'm glad you're still smiling. I am too.

It's always worth a shot.

Thanks, Mike
 
 
  sales
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Jan-24-14 9:37 AM (EST)
Do you have many pre-sold? I am planning to order one as a birthday present to my self next month. Will I be able to receive it for early April paddling?

The real question, do you have a fairly large inventory? I have thought of upgrading from the wet suit for a few years.
 
 
  Did it
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Jan-24-14 10:16 AM (EST)
Procrastination is for chickens, I sent in my order. I will post a review when it comes, and after the first time out.

Harry
 
 
  Nice
  Posted by: windwalker on Jan-24-14 6:42 PM (EST)
I sent an e-mail with a few questions yesterday and didn't hear back yet. I guess they are busy filling orders.

Let us know how it works out.

Mike
 
 
  Hmmm
  Posted by: windwalker on Jan-30-14 7:18 PM (EST)
So I sent off a second emial via their website and still no response. I think I did piss em off. Or they sold so many drysiuts they don't need to sell any more????

 
 
  I'm replying
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-30-14 8:21 PM (EST)
Windwalker -- Have not received your email. Very sorry nonetheless. Please try me at my personal email: bob@yournameherecom.com. (note two "com"s.) I will answer your questions and also try to figure out why I didn't receive your email through the website. Definitely not ignoring you intentionally.
 
 
  Contact form not working; email instead
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-31-14 8:21 AM (EST)
Thanks to Windwalker for alerting me to the fact that the contact form on our website isn't working. We're looking into the problem and will report back when it's functioning. Until then, feel free to email us at info@mythicdrysuits.com.
Anyone else who submitted questions or comments through that form: very sorry that we haven't responded. Unfortunately, I think your submissions are lost forever in the ether, so please email us directly and we WILL get back to you.
 
 
  Another update: contact form IS working
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Jan-31-14 8:41 AM (EST)
So all the input from the contact form actually has been getting to me, feeding into a spreadsheet in Google Docs that I knew nothing about. Big duh!
Now that I know they're there, I will begin replying to all those queries (there are quite a few). Again, sorry for the delay. If you sent a query through the contact form, you'll hear from us soon.
 
 
  shipping
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Feb-09-14 10:39 AM (EST)
E-mail says suits are going through customs, and shipping is planned to start 18 February. Got my credit card statement, and they have charged me for it already.
 
 
  New Stolquist for $250
  Posted by: phrancis on Jan-30-14 2:16 AM (EST)
The other year I picked up a new base model breathable Stolquist suit on closeout for $250 at my local paddle shop in Portland. It didn't have a relief zipper and only ankle gaskets, but full cuffs and a beefy zipper. That was a rare find, but I'd be curious about this new company. Exposed latex would probably see limited sun exposure and I bet the casual flat water paddler wouldn't easily tear it. I guess the long term performance of the fabric and seams would be my main concern.
 
 
  I also have an old Stolquist
  Posted by: yatipope on Jan-30-14 10:18 PM (EST)
Way back in 1999 I bought a base model Stolquist exactly like you describe for a clearance price of $225. That was almost 15 years ago so this is a good deal for the less demanding paddler. BTW that old blue drysuit lasted me about 4 years of pretty rough use all over the Olympic Peninsula whitewater canoeing the Sol Duc, Elwha, Queets, Hoh, Bogachiel, Dosewallips, the Satsops, Canyon and an unforgettable experience going down the Wynoochee Gorge at 2000cfs where I almost flushed through "landslide Cascade". I did portage and it was not easy!
 
 
  Hands On Perspective.
  Posted by: elcarajo on Feb-13-14 6:15 PM (EST)
I met with Bob Holtzman last night, and he showed me one of his Mythic Gear drysuits. I have to make a disclaimer that I have never had a drysuit, and have limited knowledge with the things. However, I was pleased to find that the materials seemed decent quality, the seams looked good, and the zippers looked outstanding.

I would call the fabric light-duty, but definitely not cheap. It would not work for commercial fishing, but I think it will be fine for kayaking and canoeing. I would have reservations about spending a lot of time on land with it, or in environments where there is a lot of contact with abrasive or sharp objects, especially in the area of one's wrists. In that sense, I think Mythic Gear will last longer in a sea-kayaking environment than whitewater or narrow creeks.

Bob told me that the sizing runs large. The medium he had with him looked a good bit larger. I normally run around XXL (sometimes smaller) and I am going to try Bob's XL next week, as he thinks there's a chance it'll work. Having not seen it, I'm neutral on the odds, but I wil update on how it fits (with an unfortunately frank assessment of my own physique).

If it fits I'll buy one and can give longer-term insight.
 
 
  Drysuit needs Layering Underneath
  Posted by: willi_h2o on Feb-15-14 12:17 AM (EST)
You'll want some room to layer some garments
underneath the dry suit fabric skin.
It most certainly won't keep you warm just by itself.

Water conducts heat away from the body
at a rate about 25 times faster than air.
You might to take a look at "undergarments"
similar to these - http://ossystems.com/undergarments/
 
 
  latest word
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Feb-21-14 9:12 AM (EST)
from Mythic is that after delays from weather and US Customs, the dry suits should arrive in Boston today, then be in Maine in a couple days.

I am looking forward to getting mine before Canoecopia so I can report on it at the club rendezvous.
 
 
  Tomorrow!
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Feb-24-14 3:30 PM (EST)
I just spoke with my freight forwarder, and I'm assured that Mythic will receive its first shipment of drysuits tomorrow (Tuesday, Feb.25). We will ship by Webnesday latest.
Bob Holtzman, President
Mythic Gear
www.mythicdrysuits.com
 
 
  Fingers Crossed
  Posted by: windwalker on Feb-24-14 7:28 PM (EST)
that I will be testing this weekend


Mike
 
 
  Shipped
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Feb-25-14 7:05 PM (EST)
Ups tracking shows

Rockland, ME, United States 02/25/2014 3:35 P.M. The shipment has been dropped off and is now at a UPS Retail Location.

Soon!
 
 
  Yep
  Posted by: blitzemall on Feb-26-14 9:03 AM (EST)
I'm looking forward to reviews.
 
 
  Tomorrow
  Posted by: windwalker on Feb-26-14 6:50 PM (EST)
According to UPS tracking, my suit will be in hand tomorrow.

I'll let you know my first impressions. On the water testing will have to wait till the weekend.

Mike
 
 
  It came today
  Posted by: Harry0244 on Feb-28-14 4:00 PM (EST)
I returned from some errands, and UPS had left the package at my front door. I noticed my only complaint as I drove up the driveway. The front of the box was not closed all the way. A single strip of packing tape was pulled along the opening between the flaps, and it had not stuck well to the box. One end of the box was crushed (UPS ?) so that the vertical corners had split, and I opened the flaps without disturbing what tape was there.

The inner bag was intact, and there was no damage to the suit, but the suit could have fallen out.

I tried it on, and will need to trim the gaskets before any extended wear, although I did not turn too blue. The hardest part for me in putting it on and taking it off was passing my shoulders through the zipper. That is MY problem as I am not as flexible as I was in my youth, and I have broad shoulders. The blue-gray color is much to my liking, and I think a good choice. I rubbed some paraffin on the outer surface of the zipper right off, and on reflection will rub some on the inner surface. I tried it over my street clothes, long johns (it was 3 F when I got up this morning), cargo pants, long sleeve T-shirt, wool socks, and pullover hoody with the hood down my back. It looks like the fit is okay. My wife, watching me thought I was torturing myself, but she does not paddle, so her opinion is not important in this matter.

A repair kit came in the bag, and after I get some bigger booties (Canoecopia next week ?) I should be ready for the first run of the year when the ice goes out.
 
 
  Packing tape
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Mar-02-14 9:42 PM (EST)
Harry: thanks for the pre-review. Packaging problem noted. All boxes will be more securely taped in the future to prevent that problem from happening again.
Bob Holtzman, President
Mythic Gear
www.MythicDrysuits.com
 
 
  chest diameter?????????
  Posted by: jjmish on Mar-03-14 10:27 AM (EST)
Hoped to place an order but the meager maximum chest size put a halt to that.

45" really?

chest diameter?

chest size limitations are probably the rate limiting step for more orders.
 
 
  Americans are Fat
  Posted by: Guideboatguy on Mar-03-14 10:52 AM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Mar-03-14 11:27 AM EST --

There was a time when not nearly as many people were too big fit an "extra large" as is the case today. In any case, lets cut the maker some slack. He's just starting out and is spending money a lot faster than it is coming in, and probably aiming to cover sizes that will fit the majority of potential buyers. Let's hope he's successful enough in doing this that catering to the upper end of the size spectrum becomes cost-effective.

I seem to remember that my Kokatat drysuit is an extra-large, but whether large or extra-large, I needed that just so the legs and arms would be long enough (they could have made a tall suit in more slender dimensions, but that would have cost a lot more). It's so huge on me that at first I usually wore my PFD on the inside, and I still had room to spare.

 
 
  kokatat sizing
  Posted by: NateHanson on Mar-03-14 12:08 PM (EST)
Actually kokatat will change the length of arms and legs on a suit for a very reasonable fee.
 
 
  What's "reasonable" depends on...
  Posted by: Guideboatguy on Mar-03-14 1:12 PM (EST)
... the thickness of your wallet. I ordered mine at Canoecopia, so besides having the chance to try on their "blanks" as a means of testing fit, I had the chance to talk at length with a factory rep. The cost of altering a suit to provide a proportionally better fit was too much for me to swallow. I'm not saying the price was unfair or anything, only that it was way too much for me to justify (I seem to recall that it was an extra few hundred dollars for any non-standard size, and I can wear a rope around my waist to take care of the issue).
 
 
  prices
  Posted by: NateHanson on Mar-06-14 8:33 AM (EST)
I believe the MSRP to add length to the arms or legs is about $70. Shortening arms or legs is about half that. More like $100 if you want to change the length of the torso.
 
 
  consumer feedback welcome
  Posted by: jjmish on Mar-04-14 11:14 AM (EST)
"There was a time when not nearly as many people were too big fit an "extra large" as is the case today. In any case, lets cut the maker some slack. He's just starting out and is spending money a lot faster than it is coming in, and probably aiming to cover sizes that will fit the majority of potential buyers. Let's hope he's successful enough in doing this that catering to the upper end of the size spectrum becomes cost-effective."
"There was a time..." well we're not talking about yesteryear.

Trying to buy his product is not giving him a break?

In what marketplace is consumer feedback not considered positive? Mistakes in basic advertizing print such as chest 'diameter' erode consumer confidence in the product.





 
 
  45" is typically an XL drysuit
  Posted by: paddlemore on Mar-06-14 9:12 AM (EST)
-- Last Updated: Mar-06-14 9:15 AM EST --

I think Bombergear lists their XL as 46-48", but Kokatat and NRS consider 45" XL.

In garment manufacturing, and ordering, size quantities are based on a curve. Medium, Large in higher quantities, followed by XL, with Small and XXL as outliers.

The trend is for the curve to shift towards XL and away from Medium. But it seems 45" is still considered XL and would cover the majority of consumers.

Starting out most companies stick with the greatest amount of coverage (Pareto Principle).

I am a fairly fit 6'2", which creates its own challenges in terms of finding garments to accommodate my height without being baggy.

 
 
  Drysuit sizes
  Posted by: bobholtzman on Mar-14-14 3:58 PM (EST)
Hey,
While I really appreciate all the good will that I've received from so many paddlers, I don't expect folks to cut us any slack. Either our products work for you and are worth your money, or not. We're a business, not a nonprofit, and we get that. But we are immensely grateful for discussions like this one, which give us a window into what paddlers want. It's by far the best means we have to improve what we do.
We are listening carefully to opinions about size grading. By far the biggest issue we hear is that our suits are not big enough in general for some paddlers, or not "stout" enough for some whose height we've got covered. If we make any one change to our next production run, it will likely be the addition of larger sizes. (BTW: we haven't heard a single complaint about quality. The other issues we hear about are features-related: some paddlers would like an overskirt/tunnel and neoprene covers over the gaskets. Both of those will raise costs, but they're not out of the question for new models.)
The terms "extra-large", XXL, etc., are only convenient shorthand for any one manufacturer's sizes, and they're rarely consistent from one brand to another. (Ever try on two pair of shoes in the "same" size from different makers?)So we won't be changing what we mean by XL. It's just not important if a Kokotat XL is bigger than a Mythic Gear XL. Anyone who follows the recommendations of any drysuit manufacturer should get the right size *for that maker's suits,* and not necessarily any other's.
Bob Holtzman, President
Mythic Gear
http://www.mythicdrysuits.com
 

Google
 
Web Paddling.net


Follow us on:
Free Newsletter | About Us | Site Map | Advertising Info | Contact Us

©2014 Paddling.net Inc.
Sweepstakes Shirt Sale