Sort of changing my opinion.
Posted by: g2d on Oct-18-12 11:48 AM (EST)
I examined their all-purpose clips, and I'm not confident they would hold in place on modern sedans. I also wonder whether they would cause small amounts of rainwater to enter the car.
Their clips are quite different from the ones on my Yakima Q-tower racks. Their clips have to go past the first weather seal, and then grasp around the inner weather seal. I can't be confident their clips would fit sedans, except by chance.
Of course, for $39, they might be worth a try. But I would not try to carry more than a single canoe or two relatively light kayaks.