There are a lot of choices out there but in your mentioning the 2009 Cayuga, is the search for performance or price? They are necessarily exclusive of each other on the used market but if you broaden your search you may find a lot of other options out there that will allow for better (funner) paddling overtime.
The Alchemy has been mentioned.
In the 14' range I would suggest finding a Venture Kayaks dealer and test paddle an Islay.
Hopefully your shopping list becomes a bit longer than two choices.
See you on the water,
The River Connection , Inc.
Hyde Park, NY
EZ-Dock modular docks
Kayak Motor Kit
Kayak & Canoe Covers
|Table of Contents|