Your #1 source for kayaking and canoeing information.               FREE Newsletter!
my Profile
Product Reviews - Send Message

You are responding to the following review:

Submitted: 08-17-2012 by Jeffrey Job

I am a new kayaker with more enthusiasm than experience so take this into consideration when reading this review. :D) I am a 54 yr old guy, 6'1 and 230 lbs, reasonably healthy with 1 year of experience.

I got a rec boat last year that was good enough for me to get excited about the sport.
This spring after a season first trip out I realized I wanted a faster and better tracking boat so I went from my Hurricane 11'6 28" beam to a Hurricane 13'5 23.5 beam and was thrilled at the improved speed and tracking and also how it handled choppy water. For 2 trips out. Then I started really researching the sport, equipment, training classes etc and started noticing size and weight recommendations and realized I had not in fact achieved Nirvana with my second boat.

I decided to take a beginner class with Kayak Acadamy here in the Seattle area to get started right. They put me in a Wilderness Tempest 180 and I loved it except by the end of the 6 hour class it started feeling like a cumbersome barge. It was large enough to do wet exits safely and obviously safety is #1 cause as they say, "the water doesn't care if you come home or not!"

I spent a week pondering my experience and decided to drop down in size so I rented the Wilderness Tempest 170 though the website info said it was a little small for me. I spent 2 days on the lake with it and loved it. However I couldn't shake the nagging feeling that getting in the cockpit was tight and wondering with my limited experience if a wet exit would be difficult.

It edged and turned well, accelerated on sprints well and speared thru 3 foot cigar boat swells with ease. It also rode right up on swell coming at 90 degrees with no problems at all. Pretty impressive for me with such limited skills. At the end of day 2 I wanted to do some bracing practice in the shallows so I was paying close attention to how far I could get up on edge before I started tipping. It did very well and I noticed that even after point of no return the boat seemed to give me almost 2 seconds to react with a bracing stroke to get it back upright. Very pleased to discover that.

All well and good till I tried a wet exit to finish a great weekend. I flipped the boat over but then my legs got hung on the thigh hooks! At class, I was in a bigger cockpit and wearing a drysuit that slid right off any contact with the boat. However on this day I was just wearing cotton baggy shorts so my wet skin, the tighter cockpit and a hint of fear and without my wife there I'm not sure I would be writing this today!! Luckily we were in 4 ft of water and I had instructed her if I had trouble to grab my PFD straps and pull me up sideways which she did.

I learned 2 things by this. I'm glad I put the ego away and prepared for trouble by not practicing alone and not insisting I was above getting in trouble. I also learned to listen to the nagging anxiety that something isn't right. I had been telling myself for 2 days I was worried about nothing every time I thought about how snug the boat felt.

Which brings me to the Perception Essence 17 Air. (I do indeed have a point.)

After my near miss I decided I wanted smaller than 180 but larger than 170. And that was tough to do as bigger guys have far fewer boats to choose from. I found the 17 online and saw that it is made in the same factory as the Tempests. In fact same company just different lines of boat. Like Buick and Pontiac are both GM. I saw the boat dimensions were very similar to the 170 but with a longer and wider cockpit. The deck is also higher so more room all around I found a dealer in Redmond, WA that had one in stock so I went in to look at it and boy was I impressed!

The 180 is made of fiberglass and costs $3000. The 170 is rotomold and costs $1600 but the p17 is made of thermoform ABS and runs $1800. $1200 less than FG And only $200 more than RM. it looks like FG and weighs alot less than the other 2 boats.

I jumped into the cockpit and knew I found my boat! No problems with being tight at all but with the adjustable leg lifters and thigh hooks and hip pads available I can snug up the fit when my skills grow. This boat handles just like the 170 so my comments about it apply to the P17 as well.

With some trepidation and the addition of a brother in law as an additional spotter I did wet exit practice and am now comfortable although still not totally proficient. I get out well but keep forgetting to hang onto the boat when coming up. The rear deck in flat and low so self rescues are relatively easy even for me.

All in all I think I have an excellent boat and an excellent value. One that my skills won't outgrow in 3 months.
The only reason I gave it 8 is because of some minor fit and finish issues and things like foam instead of plastic bulkheads and no security bar. That's also why it's $1800 and not $3000!

My advice? Research manufacturer websites and pay attention to recommended height and weight limits and then go get in it and then test paddle it. If you are concerned about fit DON'T ignore that. We rookies can get a tighter performance boat later but we have to stay alive long enough to get the experience that will take us to the next level (I hate tired sports analogies...)

Your E-mail Address:

Please enter 1234 (spam prevention, thanks!)

Your Message:

* All you need to do is submit the form above and an email message will be sent to the owner of the ad you are enquiring about.

Follow us on:
Free Newsletter | About Us | Site Map | Advertising Info | Contact Us


©2015 Inc.